Hasil Cek - Kritik Atas Kritik Matan Jonathan A.C. Brown

Kholis, Nur (2021) Hasil Cek - Kritik Atas Kritik Matan Jonathan A.C. Brown. Tajdid: Jurnal Ilmu Ushuluddin, 20 (1). ISSN p: 2502-3063, e: 2541-5018

Text (HASIL CEK SIMILARITY) Hasil Cek - Kritik Atas Kritik Matan Jonathan A.C. Brown.pdf Download (4MB)

Abstract

This paper examines the thesis of Jonathan A.C. Brown in his article, entitled The Rules of Matn Criticism: There Are No Rules. One of the critical issues highlighted by Jonathan A.C. Brown in this paper that deserves to be investigated is the potential for subjectivity in the practice of matn criticism. The matn criticism referred to here is more directed to the criticism of the substance of matn; that the content of a hadith must be in line with or not contradict several arguments (dalil) such as verses of the Koran, more authentic hadiths, historical facts, reason and senses or science. Up to now, scholars have not agreed on what can be used as indicators of matn criticism. The potential for subjectivity can also occur in determining the coherence of the content of a hadith with the arguments mentioned earlier (dalil). Using an analytical approach and the perspective of hadith sciences as an analytical tool, the author assesses what Jonathan A.C. Brown has discussed in his article as a scientific finding that deserves to be examined in depth. In addition, this paper provides a scientific argument as to why scholars place more emphasis on sanad criticism as the initial and primary step in the hadith validation process rather than matn criticism. The author also finds that the authoritative subjective theory proposed by Jonathan A.C. Brown to tackle the element of subjectivity is an idea that scientifically deserves to be used as a standard of reference and further discussion.

Item Type:	Artikel Umum
Keyword:	Kritik Matan, Subjektivitas Perawi, Ilmu Hadis
Subjects:	B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BL Religion
Divisi / Prodi:	Faculty of Islamic Studies (Fakultas Agama Islam) > S1-Hadith Interpretation (S1-Tafsir Hadith)
Depositing User:	Dr. Nur Kholis
Date Deposited:	07 Feb 2023 02:14
Last Modified:	07 Feb 2023 02:14
URI:	http://eprints.uad.ac.id/id/eprint/39589

Actions (login required)

View Item